ADDITIONAL NOTES ON TREE-TRUNK WATER-PIPES. 233 present purpose, however, it is enough to note that he remarks (pp. 200-1) that the ancient Romans used "pipes of lead, of wood, or even of earthenware." Also that the leaden pipes "were not cast tubular, as at present, but consisted of thin plates of lead bent up into the form of a cylinder, and soldered along the edge." We thus gather from our author, a man qualified to speak with authority, that down to the year 1835 even our larger towns were by no means necessarily supplied with waterworks. And we may therefore confidently assume that our smaller towns were then almost invariably devoid of them, apart from the fact that none are mentioned as possessing any. We may gather from Hydraulia that probably a chief reason for slow progress in the spread of waterworks throughout the country lay in the indifference of their advocates to the appearance of the water they supplied from the rivers, which must usually have seemed inferior to that afforded by the shallow wells. On the other hand, the possibility of sinking deep wells, with anything like certainty as to satisfactory results, became evident only as a knowledge of the geological structure of the country slowly progressed. And this knowledge was but in its infancy in 1835. The author of Hydraulia makes many remarks on the purity of water and its filtration. When speaking of the Lambeth Company's supply from the Thames, and its liability to be rendered turbid by mud and other matters, he adds :— " Though turbid water be offensive to the sight, experience has satisfactorily proved that it is not injurious to health; nevertheless, perfectly clear and limpid water being preferable for beverage, and indispensable for washing and various other domestic purposes, all the water companies will probably adopt some decisive means for purifying and rendering it thoroughly clean, so as to convey it in that condition to the inhabitants. The period may not be far distant when the inhabitants of this great and populous metropolis will perhaps have the advantage of generally receiving filtered water for their chief domestic uses, successful experiments having demonstrated its practicability. Besides the increasing taste for cleanliness, other circumstances require that improvements shall adapt its condition to the wants and habitudes of the age, and therefore its supply should be as pure and transparent as its nature will admit"' At the same time he evidently looks upon the mere desire for "transparent" water as a beverage as a squeamish weakness. He remarks (p. 324) :— "When cattle go to a clear stream to allay their thirst they often abstain from drinking till they have rendered the water turbid by stirring up the sediment with 3, From a note on p. 327 we learn—"In several recent Acts of Parliament for improving •waterworks, a clause has been introduced to compel the supplying of filtered water."