152 A EULOGY OF RAY, DALE AND ALLEN. Professor Alfred Newton, "the foundation of scientific ornitho- logy," and it is impossible to separate in it the work of Willughby from that of Ray. "From the affectionate care with which Ray has cherished the fame of his departed friend, we are in danger," says Sir James Edward Smith, "of attributing too much to Willughby and too little to himself." The classification of birds by their claws and beaks was the first serious attempt of the kind since the days of Aristotle. It was adopted, in the main, by Linnaeus, and can hardly be said to be superseded even to-day. Two years later, Ray published an enlarged edition of the work in English. On the death of Willughby's mother, in 1676, Ray's pupils were taken from him; and, after a year's residence at Sutton Coldfield, he returned to his native county, living for two years at Falkbourne Hall, near Witham, probably as tutor to the son of the owner, Mr. Edward Bullock. Possibly, as tradition has it, the fine cedar alongside the Hall may have been planted at this time by Ray. in March 1670, Ray's mother, Elizabeth Ray, died at the Dewlands, the pretty little home that he had built for her at Black Notley : thither he himself moved in the following June ; and there he spent the remainder of his days, the twenty-five most productive years of all. We must all deplore the destruction by fire of ibis sacred shrine of English science, since last the Essex Field Club visited Black Notley ! Not till 1682 have we any other work from Ray's pen ; but the Methodus Plantarum Nova of that year, an elaboration of the tables prepared for Wilkins, fourteen years before, is not only one of the corner stones of his philosophical fame, but is also a land- mark in the history of systematic botany. In it he describes the true nature of buds, speaking of them as annual plants springing from the old stock, recognises the division of flowering plants into Dicotyledons and Monocotyledons, and indicates many of the principal Natural Orders of which we now make use. He bases his system mainly, it is true, upon the fruit ; but also upon characters derived from flower and leaf. As he always does, Ray hilly acknowledges his indebtedness to his predecessors, to Caesalpinus, a century before, whom he styles "the parent of system," and to his acute but less generous contemporary, Robert Morison, of Oxford ; but the system here sketched out, though