THE WILLINGALES OF LOUGHTON. 157 connection it may be mentioned that on each occasion when the phenomenon here described was seen, the sun, although rather low, was strongly illuminating the water at the red end of the pond, the other parts being shaded by the surrounding trees. To those who may be interested in this subject and in that of the remarkable group of sulphur bacteria in general, a most useful German pamphlet may be recommended. Its title is "Die farblosen und roten Schwefelbakterien des Suss-und Salz wassers" by Dr. W. Bavendamm. (Jena, G. Fischer, 1924). Another very interesting paper on these forms is "Studies on the Sulphur Bacteria," by Dr. L. G. M. Baas-Becking in the Annals of Botany, vol. xxxix., July, 1925. THE WILLINGALES OF LOUGHTON: TO WHOM DO WE OWE EPPING FOREST? BY PERCY THOMPSON, F.L.S. [Read 28th November, 1925.] (With 3 Plates.) WITH the beginning of the second half of the nineteenth- century enclosures of Epping Forest waste, which had been on a scarcely noticeable scale before that time, suddenly became so alarmingly frequent, and so extensive, by reason of the rise in land values caused by the rapid expansion of London, that genuine public alarm was felt that, unless this action was checked, the Forest would within a few years cease to exist except in name. No less than 3,600 acres out of 6,021 acres were illegally enclosed between the years 1851 and 1875 ;1 whereas prior to 1851, barely 600 acres in all had been enclosed during two centuries and a half ! Local protests were made, but were unheeded : public opinion at the time was not organized for interference, and the manorial lords, countenanced, and even prompted, by the Government of the day, continued their policy of enclosure of the waste within their respective manors. 1 Rept. of Epping Forest Commission, 19 March, 1875.