EVOLUTIONARY CHANGES IN THE CLAY TOBACCO-PIPE 19 have been an alternative to the single 4" bowl already mentioned, for communal smoking in working-men's clubs: this construction avoided the need for special 'large-bowl' moulds, the cost of which would have been a consideration in a very small pipe-factory. COLOURED CLAY PIPES While most unglazed clay pipes were of the dull white colour associated with pipe-clay when new, they acquired a pleasant amber tint as a result of prolonged smoking. Unfortunately, this degenerated into a dirty brown with still further smoking and soaking in nicotine-stained juice : iron cradles are sometimes found into which used clay-pipes were stacked and put into the fire to be burnt clean again. When clean, they were of course restored to their uninteresting pipe-clay colour. Attempts were therefore made to produce unglazed clay pipes in more attractive tints which would stand 'firing' when the pipes needed to be cleaned. The first choice was the amber colour which old favourite pipes achieved by prolonged use and CROP of London succeeded in producing this. The family of Crop made pipes from about 1850 to 1910, giving some of their new pipes the mellow appearance of an old 'churchwarden'. When the last Crop (C. CROP) retired in about 1910, he destroyed all the old family pipe-moulds, and the secret of his pipe-colouring died with him (see fig. 8 (b)), facing page 27. Another attempt to relieve the drab monotony of pipeclay was the black pipe made by J. HARRISON in an old shed or barn behind the former "Gipsy" public-house at Highgate, London. Although Harrison is commonly believed to have used graphite to produce the 'black-lead' finish, it is quite clear that this would be a most unsuitable material to mix with pipeclay and, moreover, would not stand repeated firings: it is almost certain that manganese dioxide was his black colouring, but none of his pipes seems now to be available for chemical analysis. Black pipes of seventeenth century date have been reported from time to time: when thoroughly investigated, these usually turn out to be cases of black colouration due to the soil or water in which they have been lying since they were discarded, rather than a deliberate attempt to make coloured pipes for use. It should be emphasised that the unusual forms of pipes described on pp. 15-19 are indeed unusual, and rarely to be found in excavations.